The Top 5 Business Insurance Providers for a Nonprofit
Business Insurance Providers
Photo by Kindel Media on

You run an organization dedicated to serving your community and making a difference. The last thing you want to worry about is insurance. But without proper coverage, one disaster could wipe out your nonprofit. You need 'nonprofit business insurance' tailored to the unique needs of nonprofits so you can focus on your mission.

We've done the research to find the top 5 insurance providers that understand nonprofits. They offer specialized policies for everything from general liability to directors and officers coverage. And many provide additional benefits like risk management tools and nonprofit-focused customer service.

Keep reading to discover the insurance partners that have your nonprofit's back so you can change the world without worry. With the right coverage in place, you'll have the freedom and security to focus on what really matters - the people and causes you serve.

Understanding Business Insurance Needs for Nonprofits

As a nonprofit, insurance is non-negotiable. You have employees, volunteers, assets, and liabilities to protect. Understanding your specific needs and finding the right providers is key.

General Liability Insurance

Covers third-party claims like injuries, property damage or negligence. Must-have for most nonprofits. Look for carriers with nonprofit expertise like Hiscox, Philadelphia, or Chubb CharityFirst.

Directors and Officers Insurance

Protects board members and executives from claims arising from their decisions or actions. Essential given increased scrutiny and litigation risks. Top providers are Chubb, Travelers, and Nationwide.

Property Insurance

Covers damage or loss to your physical assets like buildings, equipment, and inventory. If you own property, get quotes from providers like GuideOne, Church Mutual, and Brotherhood Mutual. For renters, a standard business owner's policy should suffice.

Professional Liability Insurance

For nonprofits providing professional services, this covers claims of errors, omissions or negligence. Hiscox, CNA, and Chubb are reputable options.

Cyber Liability Insurance

With increasing data and privacy regulations, cyber insurance is a must. Covers costs related to data breaches, ransomware, and electronic theft. Look to Beazley, Travelers, or Chubb for tailored nonprofit cyber policies.

The right insurance mix will depend on your nonprofit's activities and risk profile. But one thing is certain - you need coverage from carriers that truly understand the unique needs and challenges of nonprofits. Do your research, compare quotes, and don't skimp on the essentials. Your organization's future could depend on it!

Top Factors to Consider When Choosing Nonprofit Business Insurance

When choosing an insurance provider for your nonprofit, there are a few key factors to weigh.

Coverage Options

The range of policies offered is important. Look for a company that provides general liability, professional liability, property, auto, and umbrella coverage tailored to nonprofits. They should offer plans for small to large organizations with options to bundle multiple policies for the best rates.

Industry Experience

Select a provider with extensive experience serving nonprofits. They will understand the unique risks and coverage needs of organizations like yours. Check their client list and number of years in the sector. An established company with nonprofit-focused services is ideal.

Competitive Pricing

Do some comparison shopping to find affordable rates. Nonprofit insurance doesn’t have to break the bank. Look for a provider offering special nonprofit discounts and packages to help reduce costs. If possible, obtain multiple quotes to find the best value.

Customer Service

Strong customer support and service are essential. Look for a provider offering nonprofit-dedicated account managers and claims representatives. They should be easily accessible by phone and email to promptly handle questions, claims, and policy changes. Read online reviews from other nonprofits to determine the quality of service provided.

Additional Services

Some companies provide extra services useful for nonprofits like online account access, risk management resources, and educational tools. Additional services show their commitment to nonprofits and can benefit your organization.

By evaluating factors like coverage, experience, pricing, service, and additional services, you'll find an insurance provider well-suited to protect your nonprofit and support its mission. With the right partner, you'll have one less thing to worry about.

- Our recommendations to improve your nonprofit's technology!

Our Top 5 Recommended Providers for Nonprofit Business Insurance

Nonprofits have unique insurance needs to protect their mission and operations. After reviewing many top providers, here are our recommendations for nonprofit business insurance:

1. Hiscox

Hiscox specializes in coverage for nonprofits and social enterprises. They offer liability, property, and D&O insurance tailored to nonprofits. Hiscox has an A+ rating from AM Best and has been serving nonprofits for over 100 years. They provide a free risk management portal with useful resources for nonprofits.

2. Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY)

PHLY has been providing insurance to nonprofits for decades. They offer very competitive rates and a nonprofit package policy that bundles general liability, D&O, property, and other coverages. PHLY has an A+ rating and receives high reviews from nonprofit clients. They also offer lots of discounts for nonprofits.

3. Chubb

Chubb is one of the largest insurers and has special nonprofit programs with very comprehensive coverage and excellent financial stability (rated A++ by AM Best). However, their premiums tend to be on the higher end. Chubb provides nonprofit insurance for organizations of all sizes, from small charities to major foundations and endowments.

4. Hartford

Hartford has been insuring nonprofits for over 200 years. They provide a broad range of coverages specifically for 501(c)(3) organizations. Hartford has an A+ rating and offers additional services like risk management education. Premiums are moderately priced. They are best for mid-size to large nonprofits.

5. Markel

Markel is a highly-rated, specialty insurer that focuses on nonprofit organizations. They offer package policies with multiple coverages at reasonable rates. Markel provides risk management tools and resources to help nonprofits reduce liabilities. They work with nonprofits of all sizes but may charge higher premiums for smaller organizations. Markel has an A rating from AM Best.

In summary, you have several excellent options for insuring your nonprofit. Compare quotes from multiple companies to find the best value based on your specific needs and budget. And be sure to reassess your insurance regularly to ensure adequate coverage as your organization grows.

- Click here for the best tools for nonprofits!

Key Coverage Options to Look for in Nonprofit Business Insurance

As a nonprofit, there are a few key types of insurance coverage you’ll want to consider to properly protect your organization.

General Liability Insurance

This covers third-party bodily injury and property damage claims. If a volunteer or client slips and falls at your office or an event, general liability insurance can help cover legal costs and payouts. Look for a policy that covers at least $1 million per occurrence and $2 million in aggregate.

Professional Liability Insurance

Also known as errors and omissions insurance, this covers claims arising from mistakes or negligence in your services. For nonprofits that provide professional advice or consulting, this is essential. Coverage of $1 million to $5 million is common.

Property Insurance

This covers damage to your physical assets like buildings, equipment, and inventory. Get coverage for the replacement cost of your property in the event of disasters like fire, theft, or natural events.

Directors and Officers Insurance

This protects your board members and executives from claims arising from their work and decisions on behalf of your organization. Lawsuits against nonprofits and their leaders are increasingly common, so this coverage is important. Look for at least $1 million in coverage.

Cyber Liability Insurance

This covers costs related to data breaches, hacking, and other cybercrimes. It helps cover expenses like victim notification, credit monitoring, data restoration, and legal fees. As nonprofits collect and store donors’ personal information, this insurance is worthwhile, with coverage of $1 million to $5 million recommended.

ForGranted Media can help you review insurance options to find the right coverage and carriers for your unique needs as a nonprofit. We want you to have peace of mind that your organization and the people behind it are protected, so you can focus on your mission.

Tips for Getting the Best Rates on Nonprofit Insurance

Getting the best rates on insurance for your nonprofit comes down to doing some homework. Follow these tips to find an affordable policy that protects your organization.

Compare Quotes From Multiple Providers

Don’t go with the first company that gives you a quote. Compare rates from at least 3-4 top insurance providers that specialize in nonprofits like GuideOne, Chubb, and Markel. Provide the same coverage details to get an apples-to-apples comparison. Go with whoever offers the most comprehensive coverage at the best price.

Bundle Policies When Possible

If you need multiple policies like liability, property, and automobile insurance, look for providers that offer bundle discounts. Bundling with one company can save you 10-30% off the total cost versus buying separate policies. Some companies like Philadelphia Insurance and Chubb are known for good bundle rates for nonprofits.

Increase Your Deductibles

A higher deductible means lower premiums but more out-of-pocket costs if you file a claim. For smaller nonprofits with limited funds, increasing your deductibles by even $500 to $1,000 per policy can result in significant savings. Just make sure you can afford the higher deductibles if you do need to file a claim.

Maintain a Good Claims History

Your claims history plays a role in determining your rates. Avoid filing small claims that cost less to pay for out-of-pocket. Go at least 3-5 years between claims when possible. Companies may drop you if you file too many claims in a short period of time. Focus on risk management to prevent issues that lead to claims.

Ask About Discounts

Regarding nonprofit business insurance, don’t forget to inquire about discounts like safe driver, security system, professional certifications, and group membership discounts. Even small discounts can add up to big savings. You may need to provide proof to qualify for certain discounts, so have that information on hand when comparing quotes.

With some time and effort, you can find nonprofit insurance at lower rates. Follow these tips and you'll be well on your way to affordable, high-quality coverage for your organization. Let us know if you have any other questions!

- Here's what we recommend for nonprofit finance!


While the options can seem overwhelming, focusing on providers with a proven track record of serving nonprofits is a great place to start. Get quotes from a few of these top-rated companies, compare their offerings, and go with the one you feel most comfortable with. Your nonprofit's future will thank you, and you'll have one less thing to worry about so you can get back to focusing on what really matters - creating positive change in the world.

About ForGranted: ForGranted Media specializes in all facets of emerging technological advancements, finance, fundraising and marketing for your nonprofit. Our sole mission is to provide with resources to become a stronger organization!

Recommended Articles

Let's Get In Touch

Ready to take the next step? We're eager to connect, understand your needs, and discuss how our expertise can make a difference in your journey. Let's get in touch!

Great achievements begin with a single conversation - let's start ours today.

Share this:

Like this:

Like Loading...
%d bloggers like this:
Verified by MonsterInsights